"With the low numbers being entered in shows today, we see a lot of placements going to "generic show dogs."In light of this, what is the level of importance that should be given to showiness & attitude vs. conformation?So many times, we see really good examples of dogs with good conformation, but they lack a showy attitude.What is the deciding factor?If it is showiness & attitude, how can we bring this out in our dogs?What is more important in the judge's eye? In other words, why does it seem showiness & attitude oftentimes seems to be put up over conformation? How do we overcome this?"

Wow, lots of questions here. Let’s see if I can answer them in order. I agree that too often “generic show dogs” win. However, this “blame” can be shared by breeders, exhibitors, and judges. Too often all succumb to the “fad dog.” Without a doubt, nothing is more important in breeding, showing and judging than breed type (and I consider soundness as part of breed type). Judges will say that we can only put up what is in front of us, but sometimes that is a copout. Good judging demands that breed type takes preference over everything else, and this starts in the whelping box, and then moves to the breed ring.

We are judging a dog show, so to some degree, an amount of showiness is part of the judge’s decision-making – but the showiness needs to be the attitude that is proper for the breed. As a matter of fact, too much of a showy attitude is incorrect for many breeds. We should not expect a Kuvasz to show the same attitude as a Cocker Spaniel. A showy attitude should play a very small part in a judge’s decision – and never more than breed type. Breed type and proper conformation should never take a backseat to breed type.

As far as bringing out attitude in your dogs – make sure you are looking for the proper attitude for your breed. Make the show ring an enjoyable place for your dog – both in practice and at shows. Proper socialization is extremely important. Do your homework and show young dogs to judges that are known to have soft hands and a good attitude with young dogs. A young dog’s first experiences are very important.

Watch judges, and if you see a judge who seems to put too much emphasis on showiness over type, simply don’t show to that judge. Of course, this assumes that you are objective and know the breed well enough to determine on what the judge is basing his decisions.

Have fun and enjoy your dog.

Thank you judge Sid Marx for your great answers to exhibitor questions.  They are thought provoking, insightful, and often humorous! 

For those of you who would like to hear more from Sid Marx, check out this article from his column  The Judge Marx The Spot in Dog News magazine or online at: https://www.dognews.com/sid-marx-0